Senior Lecturer John Chisholm Introduces Himself

John ChisholmI first entered public service in 1986 when I was a senior at Marquette University. After concluding (rashly, my physician father no doubt believed) that medical school was not my next step in life, I walked down to the Reuss Federal Building and enlisted in the United States Army. It was one of many inflection points in my life, and there is for me a sense of symmetry that I am returning to private life at Marquette University. Transitions are an opportunity for reflection, growth, and challenge. Ideally, the process is unified by a core identity rooted and formed by past and present connections to family, friends, colleagues, and community—and driven forward by meaningful purpose.

I am now the former Milwaukee County District Attorney, an identity and title I share with only one other living person—E. Michael McCann, the man who welcomed me as a prosecutor over 30 years ago. My roots in the community are deep. I was born at St Joseph’s Hospital, the same place my parents met. Dad was a Marquette medical student and mom was a Marquette nursing student. I attended Marquette High, as did three brothers, and graduated from Marquette University, joining a brother and sister who preceded me. I sadly missed the distinction of being “3M” (MUHS, MU, and MULS)—the allure of in-state tuition combined with the GI Bill proved irresistible, and I graduated from UW Law School in 1994.

I served as a line prosecutor then Team Captain in the DA’s Office from 1994 until the end of 2006, when I was elected to office, serving as the Milwaukee County DA from 2007 until January 5, 2025. Which brings me to the really important point—my excitement and gratitude for being welcomed into the Marquette Law School community by Dean Kearney.

I first introduced myself to the dean in 2006 when I was running for election—a true political novice. We had an excellent discussion in his office at Sensenbrenner Hall—prefaced by the clear understanding that he did not endorse candidates. What he did do was much more practical and useful—he introduced me to “Bob the Barber,” who plied his trade in the basement of Straz Hall. For the first-time candidate, Bob was connection gold. He knew just about everyone in the city, at least everyone who had a Marquette connection.

On the surface, the relationship between the Milwaukee District Attorney’s Office and Marquette Law School is self-evident. If you regard the DA’s office as a law firm, then it is one of the largest firms in the state (averaging 125–135 attorneys and 170 support staff), and it has a long and distinguished lineage of attorneys who graduated from MULS and entered the DA’s Office as a first career choice. For many this resulted in lifelong service to the office and community. Others matriculated to equally important jobs and careers in all branches of the public sector as well as distinguished careers in private law firms and academia.

What might not be as obvious is how influential Dean Kearney’s and the Marquette law faculty’s commitment to convening nationally respected criminal justice thought leaders at the Law School has been on the development of policy within the DA’s Office and the Milwaukee County justice system. That influence began almost immediately in 2008, when the Law School started planning for the 2009 Public Service Conference focusing on the future of community justice.

The keynote speaker was Jeremy Travis, president of John Jay College of Criminal Justice in New York City. His remarks on “The Tyranny of the Funnel”—how society’s default response of classifying people with mental health, addiction, and behavior problems as criminals created profoundly harmful structures and results—had a profound impact on the thinking of the then-nascent Milwaukee County Community Justice Council as we endeavored to remake the front end of our criminal justice system. What is now taken for granted as our “early intervention program” was heavily influenced by this moment. The remarks also formed the foundation for the 2014 National Academies report, The Growth of Incarceration in the United States: Exploring Causes and Consequences, that Travis chaired.

The following years brought other renowned speakers and seminars to address an array of issues critical to our efforts to understand and improve the quality of our criminal justice system. These led to lasting friendships and relationships, which often resulted in substantial resources coming to our community as we modeled how practitioners could work with and learn from academic partnerships. The Law School hosted conferences on improving the juvenile justice system, explaining the Community Justice Council, and allowing practitioners, students, and the community to hear from renowned thought leaders such as Robert Weisberg, Robert Sampson, Rachel Barkow, Bruce Western, Patrick Sharkey, Paul Butler, and many more. Each had an influence in furthering my personal education about this complex world that we oversimply reduce to describing as the criminal justice system.

One lasting example that influences the Marquette community today is the Near West Side Partnership. Nurtured by Marquette University and advanced by collaborators whose connections often formed in the Law School, NWSP has become a national model for private/public partnership. The partnership focuses the resources of business, law enforcement, and the university to leverage greater safety, health, and prosperity for the people and neighborhoods surrounding Marquette University. It embodies my strong belief that prosecutors should be principled problem solvers in addition to skilled criminal litigators.

I opened by saying that I hoped my transition from public service to serving the Marquette Law School community would be driven forward by purpose. I have practiced criminal law for 30 years. Much of that time was spent leading fellow public servants whose charge was to maintain the social compact with integrity and fairness. I think I’ve learned a thing or two, but the thing I’ve learned most is to value learning more deeply and to approach the intersection of law and its application to society with humility and a predisposition for constructive collaboration. I hope to share my experiences, particularly with this next generation of servants of the law, but also with the broader legal community and always with my fellow citizens in mind.

I envision a good deal of work in my new position as senior lecturer at Marquette University Law School. Focusing here only on this blog, I anticipate writing about a variety of issues, including some reflective of my growth as a prosecutor and as a system leader. Yet I hope not to be merely retrospective: I approach this work with the express intent of helping kindle in a new generation the fire to serve the nation as thoughtful, courageous, and committed legal servants.

I have been privileged throughout my life by being given the opportunity to serve others. I hope to continue that work here at Marquette University Law School.

Continue ReadingSenior Lecturer John Chisholm Introduces Himself

Celebrating Our Recent PILS Summer Fellows—Transformative Work at a District Attorney’s Office

In this one-week series (previous entries on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, and Thursday at the links), six of the 25 Marquette Law School Public Interest Law Society Fellows are sharing how public interest work has influenced their growth and shaped their professional aspirations. In this final post of the series, Morgan Millar and Evan Williams share their experiences working with the Kenosha County District Attorney’s Office.

Morgan MillarBy Morgan Millar, 2L

This past summer, I had the incredible opportunity to intern at the Kenosha County District Attorney’s Office. As I reflect on my experience, I feel compelled to share how this internship has profoundly shaped my future career aspirations, particularly in criminal law.

From the moment I stepped into the office, I was struck by the unmistakable commitment to justice that permeated the environment. Every day, I witnessed legal professionals passionately advocating for individuals’ rights, navigating the intricate legal system, and striving to ensure fairness and equality. This immersive experience reinforced my belief that pursuing a career as a lawyer is not just a job for me; it is a calling grounded in my desire to safeguard the rights of individuals and advocate for justice.

A Commitment to Justice

During my internship, I was actively involved in a range of essential tasks that provided me with insight into the workings of criminal law. I drafted criminal complaints, participated in charging decisions, and conducted legal research on criminal statutes, case law, and procedural rules. Each of these activities deepened my understanding of the complexities of the legal system and the critical role lawyers play in upholding the principle of justice.

I contributed to the preparation of briefs and trial materials, gaining a firsthand understanding of how legal arguments are crafted and presented. Representing the state in court proceedings was particularly meaningful; I actively engaged in hearings and trials under the guidance of experienced assistant district attorneys. These experiences allowed me to negotiate with defense counsel, draft plea deals, and present arguments on matters such as bond, probable cause, and sentencing recommendations.

Navigating Complexities

Collaboration was a key theme of my internship. I assisted with gathering pertinent information and evidence for ongoing investigations from law enforcement agencies. This involved reviewing police reports and analyzing camera footage to identify key evidence for trial. I learned that thorough investigation is vital in building a strong case, and it underscored the importance of teamwork in the pursuit of justice.

One of the most valuable experiences was assisting in teaching new law enforcement officers the  courtroom testimony procedures. This not only enhanced my understanding of courtroom dynamics but also provided insights into law enforcement responses and investigative procedures. Additionally, my eight-hour ride-along shift with a Kenosha police officer was a revelation, offering a unique perspective on the challenges law enforcement officials face and the critical role they play in the legal process.

Looking Forward

I am deeply grateful for the extraordinary opportunity I had this summer with the Kenosha County District Attorney’s Office and am delighted to have been given the opportunity to continue my work there during my 2L year as well as to return this coming summer. The invaluable mentorship and support I received from everyone in the DA’s office, especially my supervisory team, have profoundly shaped my journey. Additionally, the opportunity to observe and practice in front of Judge Angelina Gabrielle taught me invaluable lessons about courtroom presence and procedure, reinforcing my desire to pursue a career in prosecution.

In conclusion, my summer at the Kenosha County District Attorney’s Office has been transformative. It has solidified my commitment to pursuing a career in law, specifically in criminal law, where I can actively contribute to the principles of justice, due process, and the safeguarding of individual rights. I am excited to embark on this journey, armed with the knowledge and inspiration gained from my experiences this summer, ready to advocate for fairness and equality in our legal system. Thank you to everyone at the DA’s office for this extraordinary opportunity and for believing in me and thank you to the Marquette University Law School for the Public Interest Law Society fellowship that supported me.

Evan WilliamsBy Evan Williams, 2L

I came to law school with a desire to be a litigator. When the chance to spend my summer as a Marquette Law School Public Interest Law Society summer fellow with the Kenosha County District Attorney’s Office was presented to me (including the opportunity to practice before judges under the Wisconsin Supreme Court’s student practice rule), I was all in.

At the Kenosha County DA’s Office, the summer interns were thrown into legal work quickly. We spent one week learning the basics of the office—such as where the attorneys were located, how to maneuver around the courthouse, how to navigate the county’s data system, and how to draft a complaint—then we were thrown into the fire. My first appearance in court was for an initial appearance hearing in front of Court Commissioner William Michel. I remember when I walked into intake for the hearing my heart was pounding, my stomach had dropped, and my hands were dripping with sweat. I felt like I was back in my baseball career, walking up to the plate with two outs in the bottom of the 9th inning and the winning run in scoring position.

This feeling only intensified until my number was called. When my file was finally called, I was surprised I was able to hear it over the sound of my pounding heart. I made my appearance— “Evan Williams on behalf of the State”—and made my bond argument, which probably only lasted 30 seconds. The commissioner adopted my recommendation, and my first hearing was completed. The rush that came over my body was euphoric. I immediately asked for another file, and the cycle of nerves reappeared.

At this moment, I definitely knew I wanted to be a litigator. As the days went on, I gained more and more legal experience. I began handling preliminary hearings, where I would question witnesses, conduct sentencing hearings, and even handle a traffic trial on my own. However, the biggest challenge that summer was not the work itself but rather the walk into the courtroom each day.

The nerves I felt when getting ready to make an argument were different than the nerves I felt walking into the courtroom. The former nerves were the good kind. The nerves I felt walking into the courtroom were not. Walking down the halls of the courthouse, I would see the victims, defendants, and their families and friends. Probably 90% of them, like myself, were Black or brown. But that wasn’t the surprising part. As a Black man, I am not oblivious to the racial disparities that have resulted from our country’s legal system. The difficult part was the look I received as I walked into the courtroom. The look I received gave me this sense of betrayal. It made me feel as if I was in the wrong place. For a while, I tried my best to look down and avoid eye contact. I thought by avoiding contact this gut-wrenching feeling would go away, but that was not the case.

The feeling stayed until I learned about the importance of dignity and prosecutorial discretion. My supervising attorney was a white middle-aged man. Although he couldn’t completely relate to my experience, I knew from our conversations that he was not oblivious to the negative results of our legal system. He understood that not everyone has the same interpretation of the word “justice.” But most importantly, he understood that no matter whether you are a victim or defendant, at your core, you are a human being. A human being who deserves dignity and respect. From him, I learned that being a prosecutor is not only about getting a conviction but helping your community. This means that it is both about helping victims receive the help they need but also trying to help better position the defendant not to return to the system. And although the looks might not have disappeared, by the end of the summer I was walking into the courtroom with my head high.

Continue ReadingCelebrating Our Recent PILS Summer Fellows—Transformative Work at a District Attorney’s Office

Celebrating Our Recent PILS Summer Fellows—New Perspectives Gained

In this continuing series, with contributions by Marquette law students who were Public Interest Law Society summer fellows during 2024 (earlier entries being here, here, and here), we see some of the diverse ways Marquette law students are engaging with public interest legal work and how it shapes their futures as attorneys. Today, Sydney Gang reflects on her summer internship with Legal Action of Wisconsin’s Eviction Defense Project, where she noticed the relationship between empathetically engaging with clients and determining potential defenses to eviction.

Sydney GangBy Sydney Gang, 2L

“Perspective can change everything” is what I always tell my friends. I believe there are endless perspectives that can change the way we view things. Sometimes when we think we have seen something from all angles, a new one appears and can completely change our opinion or viewpoint. The PILS Summer Fellowship gave me an entirely different perspective of the Milwaukee community, which I have never seen before and which I will carry into my legal career.

Before my internship, the thought of being evicted never even crossed my mind.

In my Wisconsin hometown community, evictions were unheard of—at least by me. My parents worked incredibly hard to give my brother and me everything, even though they came from poverty themselves. Since I have never experienced poverty and always had secure housing, I lacked the perspective of those who were facing an eviction or who are at risk of being evicted.

My PILS fellowship, working at Legal Action of Wisconsin, woke me up. On the first day of my summer internship in Legal Action’s housing unit, I was thrown into small claims court. If I had two words to describe small claims court, it would be organized chaos. Every bench was filled, lawyers dashed in and out of the courtroom to talk with clients, commissioners called names, and an overall gloomy mood sat in the room.

Among the organized chaos, though, was a courtroom full of stories—each one with a unique perspective. Eventually, when I was able to represent clients myself under the student practice rule, I would listen to their stories to better leverage their position in court. Although I had never been in their shoes, they explained what it was like to live in fear of losing their home and possessions. Many cried, got angry, or were quiet. Even if I was incapable of truly understanding their position, listening to them helped me appreciate at least to some degree what they were going through.

After hearing their story and collecting the facts of their cases, their stories made issue-spotting much easier than when I struggled in school with it. I was able to come up with possible defenses and give them a list of options that I could present to opposing counsel. When I would offer the clients different possibilities, their entire demeanor would change. Suddenly their eviction became much more manageable to overcome. The relief on their faces was truly rewarding. Even in cases involving a simple seal, clients sometimes broke down and cried, thanking me because they could finally find safe, secure, and affordable housing without an eviction on their record.

Volunteering had always been a back burner thought because I didn’t feel myself relating to the clients and was too focused on my own problems in life. I saw volunteering as more of a chore than having a greater purpose. However, after taking cases from start to finish (eviction cases don’t take long), where you see the impact on someone’s life, it was apparent how meaningful volunteering can be, how great the need is, and how few pro bono resources exist. Suddenly, making it to dinner on time was on the back burner.

You’re never done pursuing other perspectives, is what I will keep telling my friends. When you think you’ve seen it all, you haven’t. Although you will never truly be in the shoes of someone else, you can try your best. By showing empathy and understanding to others, you not only make them feel heard, but you also can leverage their position better in a legal setting and achieve client goals more effectively. The PILS Fellowship experience with Legal Action of Wisconsin was an invaluable experience that I will carry with me into my legal career and beyond when I need to see things from a new perspective.

Continue ReadingCelebrating Our Recent PILS Summer Fellows—New Perspectives Gained