Why Barry Bonds Must Be Convicted

Posted on Categories Criminal Law & Process, Federal Criminal Law & Process, Sports & Law

Last week, noted sportswriter Sally Jenkins used her Washington Post column to ask why the United States government was devoting so many resources to the prosecution of baseball star Barry Bonds.  Why, she asks, with so many problems in the country, are we expending so much effort trying to convict the all-time home run leader of the crime of perjury, when his real offense, the use of illegal drugs, is so relatively minor.  Better, she says, to let Major League Baseball deal with this problem, and let the federal government tackle people who are guilty of more serious offenses.

To my mind, Jenkins has it all wrong.  It is especially important that Bonds be convicted.  In the United States, baseball has always been more than just a game.  From the 1870’s onward, major league baseball has been equally entertainment and morality play.  Every season involves the enactment of a public ritual that emphasizes and validates our most important common values.  In a society that celebrates individualism, but only within the constraints of moral norms, baseball celebrated individual accomplishment but always within the context of team play.

The ability of ordinary young men to rise from rural pastures or urban sandlots, through the minor leagues, to the major leagues reiterated the “rags to riches” vision of the United States as a society of unlimited opportunity for people with natural talent and self-discipline.  Even the annual example of once great players having to step aside because of age or injury emphasized that in the larger society each generation had to give way to the next and that current ability, rather than reputation or social status, was what really mattered.  In other words, major league baseball was a kind of perfect social Darwinist fable.

One of the central rules of American society has long been that while aggressiveness and cleverness are to be rewarded, cheating is not an acceptable path to excellence.

Rules of lesser importance, like the ones that govern play on the field, can be bent without undermining the basic message of baseball, but the fundamental rule that only honest effort should be rewarded is not to be violated.  Sneaking a spitball past the umpire or only pretending to touch second base while turning a double play are acceptable actions, but bribing an umpire or an opponent or physically harming an opponent while off the field are not.

Obviously this was always been more myth than reality, and traditional American values have been under attack since the 1960’s.  Nevertheless, the myth of American values remains an important myth and one that plays an important role in insuring social cohesion.

What Barry Bonds did by using prohibited performance enhancing substances and then lying under oath about his actions was to violate not just the integrity of baseball but of core American values as well.  Moreover, violating them in the context of baseball made his actions even worse.  That he, and his steroid-enhanced cohorts, robbed Henry Aaron and Roger Maris of the home run records, the most prized examples of worthy accomplishment, makes his offense especially reprehensible.

Because playing Major League Baseball has been the dream of tens of millions of American males for nearly a century and a half, we have a certain quiet sympathy for those who might violate the merit principle to obtain a goal made unattainable by nature’s denial of physical talents.  The baseball-loving, but physically inept college chemistry instructor of the movie “It Happens Every Spring” comes to mind, as does the middle-aged insurance salesman who sells his soul to the Devil for a chance to play in “Damn Yankees.”  Bonds, however, deserves no such sympathy since his God-given talents made him one of the greatest players of his generation, making his turn to steroids nothing more than the expression of deplorable greed.

To convict Barry Bonds of steroid-related perjury is to reaffirm the continued significance of values that have long been central to the American experience.  Texas v. Johnson notwithstanding, no one has the right to desecrate a national symbol and certainly not for no reason other than personal aggrandizement.

4 thoughts on “Why Barry Bonds Must Be Convicted”

  1. I agree that Barry Bonds should be held fully accountable for his conduct, although Sally Jenkins raises a valid point regarding the substantial federal government resources being expended to prosecute him for perjury. Although Bonds’ conduct (i.e., anabolic steroid usage) violated the integrity of baseball, this is not the underlying basis of the criminal offenses for which he is being prosecuted (i.e., lying under oath and knowingly giving false testimony). To vindicate the harm to the very legitimate public values you identify (e.g., depriving baseball fans of honest athletic competition in accordance with the rules of the game), a criminal prosecution for fraud and the usage of anabolic steroids solely to enhance athletic performance would be more appropriate charges.

  2. I like the notion that baseball enacts our moral values and is, therefore, more than a game, but I would substitute “dominant ideology” for “moral values.” From an ideological perspective, American beliefs in individualism, the rags to riches myth, and the rise of the most talented can be combined into the idea that self-enrichment is both admirable and normative. As the Gordon Gekko character shouts in “Wall Street,” “Greed is good!” But even American greed has boundaries, as historical figures stretching from the Robber Barons to Bernie Madoff have learned the hard way. The dominant ideology, after all, also prescribes harsh punishment for the unduly greedy and morally flawed.

  3. I agree with everything that you have said, Bonds should be held responsible for using steroids and tarnishing Major League Baseball. The worst part of it is that Bonds never even needed steroids to be considered one of the greatest players to ever play the game.

    The bottom line is that everyone knows that Bonds used anabolic steroids and then lied about it in court, any sabermetrician or even casual baseball fan knows that. So either give Bonds jail time for his criminal charges or leave Bonds alone. The fact that they have been dragging this case on for so long is absurd, especially when everyone knows what happened.

  4. The story of Barry Bonds, like several other athletes is really a sad tale. Like Tiger Woods and now Joe Paterno, the truly important part of their lives was never being the greatest- it was in preserving their greatness through the sanctity of their integrity.

    The year before Bonds hit his 73 home runs,he did a promotional event for the company I worked for as part of an ESPN promotion. He spoke so eloquently and it was so heart-felt, that it only made my disappointment in his behavior grow.

    As long as it takes, he should be prosecuted to the fullest. If interested, you can read about my bonding with Barry on my blog at

Join the Conversation

We reserve the right not to publish comments based on such concerns as redundancy, incivility, untimeliness, poor writing, etc. All comments must include the first and last name of the author in the NAME field and a valid e-mail address.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.