David T. Prosser, Jr., a prominent figure in Wisconsin for the last forty-five years, held many significant positions during his distinguished career of public service: Wisconsin Supreme Court Justice, Speaker of the Wisconsin Assembly, Commissioner of the Wisconsin Tax Appeals Commission, and Outagamie County District Attorney, among others. But after he passed away this month at the age of 81, those who gathered to celebrate his life remembered him not only as a hard worker and skilled jurist but also—and perhaps more importantly—as a trusted mentor, loyal friend, and devoted family member.
In my personal experience, Justice Prosser certainly deserved those accolades. I served as his law clerk during the Wisconsin Supreme Court’s 2004-2005 term. That year we worked elbow to elbow, and I observed firsthand his skill as a writer, his work ethic, and his wry wit. Upon arriving at the state capitol in early August 2004, fresh out of Marquette Law School, I was as nervous as could be. Justice Prosser immediately put me at ease, and although I made many mistakes, he never lost patience with me. That year on the Court was perhaps the greatest experience of my professional career and I often reflect on those times. I certainly would not be where I am today without him.
As with many of those whose lives he touched, Justice Prosser always had my best interests in mind. He kept in touch with me and followed my career even long after I worked for him. A few years after my clerkship had ended, I needed a letter of recommendation in a short time frame during a busy period at the court. He agreed to write on my behalf. After apologizing for the quick turnaround, I asked when he might be able to get it in the mail—to which he answered, “we’ll see.” The next evening, there was a knock at my door. There on my doorstep was Justice Prosser, with the letter in hand. He had not only written it in less than a day, but also driven two hours each way to ensure it arrived on time. I invited him in, but he declined, saying, “I’m sure you have better things to do than have dinner with me.” His humility was one of his defining features. My experience was not unique. Those gathered at his funeral told many stories of a similar nature, explaining how Justice Prosser dropped everything to help a friend or family member in need.
Justice Prosser was a great friend of Marquette Law School, often appearing at events, lectures, dinners, and the like. Many of his clerks were Marquette lawyers, and they went on to successful careers as judges and lawyers in a variety of practice settings. He was featured in the Summer 2017 edition of Marquette Lawyer magazine, highlighting how he enjoyed hiring law clerks from Marquette and how much they helped him.
The previous year, in an interview with the Wisconsin State Bar on the occasion of his retirement from the Wisconsin Supreme Court in 2016, Justice Prosser said he wanted to be remembered as an important decision-maker, an independent thinker, and a storyteller. He was certainly all those things, but also much more to those of us who had the good fortune to know him. As we continue our journeys without him, we honor the person he was and the life he led. Rest in peace, Justice Prosser. You will be missed.
Thanksgiving truly is an extraordinary celebration. Its invitation to pause and take inventory of the people whom and events in our life that we are grateful for quietly renews one’s spirit.