Best of the Blogs: One Lump or Two?

November 2 is fast approaching, and the nation is awaiting the election results to see whether the Tea Party Movement will be revealed to be a force in American politics or an over-hyped media sensation.  This week’s “Best of the Blogs” feature provides everything a political junkie needs to learn more about the Tea Party Movement.

The obvious starting point might be Butch Cassidy’s (or Paul Newman’s) famous question, “Who are those guys?”  Amy Gardner at the Washington Post tries to answer that question here (hat tip to Steven Easley).  Despite her best efforts, a definitive picture of the Movement remains elusive:

[A] new Washington Post canvass of hundreds of local tea party groups reveals a different sort of organization, one that is not so much a movement as a disparate band of vaguely connected gatherings that do surprisingly little to engage in the political process.

Continue ReadingBest of the Blogs: One Lump or Two?

Libertarians and Liberals

It is a peculiar characteristic unique to our country that Americans talk about political issues in constitutional terms, thereby turning every policy debate into an argument over basic principles.  That was my thought when I read about Senate candidate Rand Paul and his “Constitutionalist” view that the federal government has no right to dictate the behavior of private enterprises.  Mr. Paul came under fire last week for suggesting that the Civil Rights Act of 1964 went too far when it prohibited discrimination by private businesses.  You can read more here (astute students in my Constitutional Law class will observe that Mr. Paul inspired one of the questions on my final exam this year).

Paul objects to federal policies regulating business due to his reading of the U.S. Constitution.  His political philosophy might best be characterized as extreme libertarianism.  Following the objectivist principles of Ayn Rand, he argues that the public should be left to their own devices and that greater social benefits will accrue naturally over time from the enlightened (and rational) self-interest of individuals.  Ironically, Paul’s embrace of self-interest as a moral good in itself is directly at odds with the view of the Framers of the Constitution.  The people who designed our constitutional system spent much time criticizing the biases, prejudices, and self-interested motivations of the general public.  The system of government that they created was intended to ameliorate the very aspects of human nature that objectivists like Rand Paul celebrate.

Continue ReadingLibertarians and Liberals

Health Reform and Racial and Ethnic Health Disparities

One of the most troubling aspects of the U.S. health care system is the existence, and extent, of racial and ethnic health disparities. Research has amply documented that members of racial and ethnic minority groups receive fewer health care services and lower quality health care than non-minority patients (see, for example, the rather damning portrait drawn by the Institute of Medicine’s 2003 study titled “Unequal Treatment: Confronting Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Health Care”). These disparities remain even when insurance status, socioeconomic status, and other important factors are controlled for in scientific studies.

There are many likely causes of race- and ethnicity-based health disparities. Among them: patient-level variables such as cultural preferences, mistrust of health care providers, and degrees of knowledge; system-level factors such as the geographic availability of health care providers, the use of managed care in publicly sponsored health care programs, and a general lack of institutional funding for language interpretation and translation services; and provider-level variables such as prejudice, stereotyping, and clinical uncertainty when treating minority patients.

Yet for all the evidence showing the existence of racial and ethnic health disparities, government agencies, health care providers, and health plans and insurers do not routinely collect data pertaining to patients’ race, ethnicity, and primary language.

Continue ReadingHealth Reform and Racial and Ethnic Health Disparities
Newer Posts
Older Posts